Tuesday, August 30, 2011

Why is Madagascar Treated Differently by US State Department?

I recently joined Twitter, and almost immediately got into a potentially interesting discussion with the US Embassy in Madagascar. The new Charge d'Affaires was set to arrive, so the USEmbassy tweeted:

USEmbassy-Madagascar
The new ChargĂ© d´Affaires of the American Embassy arrives soon - what do you think he should know about ?
28 Aug via web
To which I replied:
Chris Planicka
Why there is still no US Ambassador to Madagascar. Actually, we all would like to know why...
28 Aug via web
Which led to this:
USEmbassy-Madagascar
In order to have an ambassador, we would need to have a recognized government to which we could present their credentials
33 minutes ago via web


Caught up? Now, I should first point out that the American Embassy staff that I met in Madagascar were fantastic and put on some of the best programs in the country. My issue is not with the embassy itself but with the US State Department's stance on Madagascar.

To respond to the USEmbassy's tweet: Of course I know the literal reason there is no current US Ambassador in Madagascar. An unrecognized government's country cannot have an official US Ambassador. But, why are we (the United States) continuing to play out foreign policy idealism in Madagascar while fully utilizing realpolitik in pretty much every other country? The Malagasy people continue to suffer, due in large part to lack of full USAID funding, a partially-functioning US Embassy (with no Ambassador nor related funding programs, like the Self-Help Fund or the Democracy and Human Rights Fund), the removal of the Millennium Challenge Account (of which Madagascar was the first country to qualify for), and most importantly the suspension of AGOA. Many have begun calling for an end to pointless sanctions which are not achieving the political aim of bringing the Rajoelina government to the negotiating table (for an example, see the link in this post under #3).

Now, I am no fan of how Andry Rajoelina came to power, nor am I a supporter of any of his government's actions since taking that power. But, like it or not, he has been in power for two-and-a-half years now. The United States recently recognized the National Transitional Council in Libya as the legitimate government over a month before it took the capital. In fact, the bloody civil war is still continuing. In Somalia, the United States recognizes the Transitional Federal Government, despite their almost complete powerlessness in governing that country. In a closer comparison, US Ambassador Bisa Williams presented her credentials to an interim government months before post-coup elections were held in Niger.

It seems like everywhere else, the United States is utilizing a realpolitik foreign policy. They focus on practical implications in dealing with governments that are in power, no matter the means or extent of this power. But in Madagascar, the US State Department clings to an idealistic belief that all governments it recognizes must come to office via the ballot box. It is time to treat Madagascar as practically as the United States treats everyone else... the Malagasy people deserve it.

Monday, August 29, 2011

Jeff Sachs' Army? A more thorough look at why I am studying in Columbia's MDP program

A week ago, I began orientation for my graduate program in Development Practice. We spent some time discussing what "Development Practice" is, what the degree stands for, and why we wanted to study in this field. Although I have previously written a brief introduction to my program, it occurred to me that many others would like to know details about the issues mentioned above (the acronym alphabet soup alone can be daunting; for instance, I am pursuing an MPA-DP from SIPA and EI at CU)*.

Many people working or interested in development associate the MDP (Masters of Development Practice) program at Columbia University with one man. Indeed, the global MDP program, and more directly the Millennium Villages Project that is partially associated with the MDP program, are seen as his brainchild. In reality, the MDP program was born out of the Millennium Development Goals and a team of 20 development experts looking to improve education for development practitioners. Still, the association has stuck, as when I told my friends in Peace Corps about my program and they responded with, "Oh, so you're joining Jeff Sachs' Army?"

Jeff Sachs' Army. This comment has stuck with me. A man committed to ending poverty forming a cadre of "troops" for his cause? Perhaps I should explain a bit further. Like it or not, for years now development issues have been debated as either Pro-Sachs or Anti-Sachs. (**) Dr. Sachs has strongly expressed his view (in just about every media form available) that massive new commitments of aid are necessary to help third world countries break out of the poverty trap. This strong stance has, of course, created a backlash within the aid/development community. The most notable critic has been Dr. Easterly, who feels that responsible aid is important but insufficient to break out of the poverty trap (in fact, there is no "poverty trap," as he sees it as due to poorly-designed tests).

Anyway, Dr. Easterly is just one of many critics of Dr. Sachs floating around the blogosphere. Since many see the Millennium Villages Project as a Sachs pet project that refuses to accept criticism, I would imagine they would see our MDP program (which has a direct link with the Millennium Villages) as creating more Disciples of Sachs. Therefore I wanted to refute this idea, and show how the goals of the program are in line with the overall suggestions being made by many in the blog-world for improving aid and development. And to spice up this post a bit, I thought I'd tackle this with a little dialogue:

-What is Development Practice?
--In short: the practice of development.
-I guess I should have seen that one coming... can you elaborate?
--Well, some programs focus on development economics or theory or studies. These programs are usually highly academic and sometimes overly theoretical. They are very necessary to the overall understanding and implementation of development. Development Practice aims to take the successful, evidence-based theories and practices and implement them in projects in the developing world.
-Alright, and what is the MDP program? (****)
--The Masters of Development Practice program is a masters program consisting of two years of coursework in the four disciplines of natural, social, health, and management sciences, combined with cross-sectoral field training, to produce versatile development practitioners.
-Yikes, sorry I asked you to elaborate before. Can you say that in a shorter way?
--Well, it is an interdisciplinary graduate degree that aims to prepare students to better address the multi-faceted problems of development.
-Still too many big words...
--Ok. It is kind of like an MBA for Development Practice.
-MBA! Wait, how is it "kind of like an MBA?" MBA's are for business-folk, right?
--First, like an MBA, the MDP is a professional degree. Professionalizing the aid and development world is a necessity at this point. But don't take my word for it, here's aid blog Tales From The Hood: "Professionalizing the aid sector – by definition applying standards which would mean excluding non-professionals from practice – means improving the quality of service provided to the poor." (*****) The other reason I compared it to an MBA is because the MDP is also a versatile degree. Upon graduating, an MDP'er should be able to succeed in development work in any sector without necessarily being an expert in one field.
-Wait, not an expert? Isn't that bad?
--I said not an expert in one field. An MDP graduate is an expert. She or he is an expert in development practice (thanks to Professor Glenn Denning for that one). A development practitioner could be a "general manager" type, but could also be an economist or an agronomist or a health worker... with the ability to understand complex problems and opportunities across sectors. The MDP graduate is not limited to a single field of expertise.
-Ok, that sounds pretty good. So you're taking the ideas and theories from the academic world and putting them into practice?
--In a way. A development practitioner utilizes evidence-based concepts and ideas in the field. But, a good development practitioner knows that there is no One Right Answer. An idea that works in India will need to be adapted, or maybe even scrapped altogether, in Liberia. The MDP program promotes an understanding of results and the skills to change the program as indicated by these results. Trial and error, when one learns from those errors and they are on a small-scale, is an important part of development practice. Take a look at the blog A View From the Cave, where the author talks about Tim Harford and the need to learn from one's failures.
-I know that blog! Doesn't that same article also talk about Groupthink within the development world? Aren't you concerned about intellectual stagnation being in a program devoted solely to the MDGs, MVP, and the teachings of Sachs?
--Actually, the groupthink can be dangerous, and it has seemed to invade the blogosphere recently as well, stifling debates about important issues. Check out Aid Thoughts for more on this. But I reject the idea that the MDP program is a reactionary leviathan opposed to new or different ideas. In fact, quite the contrary. I think the MDP program wants to implement effective ideas, and encourage constructive debate. This is crucial, as a quality development practitioner needs to critically analyze every idea and its effects in a particular context. No idea, including the Millennium Villages, is sacrosanct to our program. In my current class, we have students from all over the world, with wildly disparate yet impressive experiences. They question everything, using their experiences as evidence for or against a particular development strategy. But most impressive is their optimism and excitement. Too often in the world of development, you run into burnt-out and jaded pessimists. These fellow graduate students are committed to combating poverty, and are critical and creative in finding the solutions to do so.
-Wow. You kind of went off on a tangent there, huh? Any final thoughts about why you chose this program?--As I mentioned in an earlier post, linked to at the top of this page, the Columbia MDP program is full of amazing faculty and great courses. It has links with the world-renowned School of International and Public Affairs and the Earth Institute. But after (only!) a week of orientation, I realize the main draw of the MDP program is the people. As some of you know, I can be pretty cynical regarding aid and development sometimes. This comes mostly from frustrations during my time in Madagascar. So I was very excited to learn that my classmates (and really everyone associated with the program) are enthusiastic, optimistic, intelligent, and incredibly passionate about development. Maybe some of the will rub off when I go through a cynicism phase...
-...That got pretty sappy, pretty fast. But I'm glad you're happy, so far. Maybe I will check back in after a few months, after real classes have started and the shiny gleam of a new program is gone...



* = That's the Masters of Public Administration in Development Practice from the School of International and Public Affairs and the Earth Institute at Columbia University. Phew...
** = Which, if said quickly enough, sounds like either (1) a jazz debate or (2) an argument within a 1960s social movement about interpersonal relationships
*** = Professor Easterly also wrote one of my favorite books on aid and development, The White Man's Burden: Why the West's Efforts to Aid the Rest Have Done So Much Ill and So Little Good (but this may have been because I read it in Peace Corps at the height of my cynicism!)
**** = Note: there are many MDP programs around the globe, but for this article I am mostly talking about Columbia's MDP program since I know the details the best (and am, you know, attending it)
***** = For those of you reading at home, you can see the quoted article here and more here. Professionalizing the sector is a major theme of Tales From The Hood and many other blogs.

Saturday, August 27, 2011

Two Issues Affecting Madagascar to Mull Over This Weekend (and a video)

I've started my grad school program (more on this soon), so I have not been able to write much here. I wanted to share a story and a video about issues affecting Madagascar. First, there is this article from last weekend. The BBC documents the treatment of Malagasy women taken to the Middle East as maids and other domestic workers. The conditions are horrendous and equate to modern-day slavery. It is worth remembering that the Malagasy have a long history of being abducted by many cultures to live as slaves. This history is due to Madagascar's location between Asia, Africa, and the Middle East. Malagasy slaves were especially prevalent in South Africa, where white settlers used them for work as a way to avoid interacting with the native South African cultures. It is sad to see this type of treatment continuing in the modern age. I expect little is made of this issue because of Madagascar's current international isolation, but at least the current government was able to eventually evacuate many of these victims.

The other issue is AIDS. Check out the below video, where the Tana Gospel Choir sing a Malagasy version of "I Will Survive" to raise AIDS awareness (fanentanana @ SIDA). It is pretty awesome.



You can check out more on the Tana Gospel Choir at their website. Bon Weekend!

Sunday, August 21, 2011

A Thought About Resolving (non-violent) Conflict

Having recently moved to NYC, I've had a lot of interesting blog posts waiting in my Google Reader for me to get settled. A few examples that jumped out at me:

-After my recent brief trip to Ethiopia, I was very interested in this article about the Ethiopian government's abuses and connections to UK development funds
-Keeping the above mindset, and adding beer! Ethiopia and Heineken: an interesting snippet on economic growth. I cannot vouch for either of the beers mentioned, as the only one I recall drinking was St. George Beer (quite tasty too!)
St. George Beer, with the historic sites of Axum as a backdrop
-Now on to my interest in Agriculture: Crop insurance for small farmers in Bolivia. Here's the money quote:
Yet Miguel Solana, a programme officer who runs the Bolivia project at the ILO, says: "Credit is not the only solution." He believes farmers in Latin America have wrongly been given loans for far too long, when they would have derived greater benefit from an insurance policy instead.
 -As a History major in undergrad who is now pursuing a graduate degree in Development, I could not agree more with this article

Most of these articles, and many others, made me nod in agreement (or sometimes shout in disagreement). But one in particular hit me and made me think. The article was a write up about the unresolved conflict in Israel by Stephen Walt of Foreign Policy. While interesting in itself, it was a few lines from the post's opening that caught my eye:
...unresolved conflicts are dangerous precisely because they provide opportunities that extremists can exploit, they harden perceptions and images on both sides, and most importantly, they can always get worse. So when a promising opportunity to settle a conflict arises, wise leaders should pursue them energetically. 
Settling conflicts early seems like a no-brainer. The reason these lines made me stop and think is because this does not seem to be the case in non-violent conflicts. For instance, when unresolved issues drag on and on in American politics, most people seem to become apathetic to the issue and just want it to end (1). A better example is the always-interesting (to me) case of Madagascar. The country's political conflict has gone on for two-and-a-half years now, remaining mostly non-violent during this time (2). As the conflict has dragged on, the competing sides, current President Rajoelina and the 3 Ex-Presidents (3), have not come any closer to agreement. However, many other politicians have grown tired of the debates and disagreements (and the Malagasy people certainly have). Many opposition politicians have left their old parties to either join Rajoelina's government or form new "unity" parties (4). It seems like the longer the conflict has gone on, the less that people have really cared about it. The SADC and AU failed to resolve the conflict early on; now, they have forgotten about Madagascar and the country has moved on. I doubt there will ever be a proper resolution to this conflict (in the same way that there was not a proper resolution in 2002). But Rajoelina will continue to rule as he sees fit, and the rest of the political establishment will continue to fall into line. As for the average Malagasy person, as is always the case whether the politicians are fighting or agreeing, life will go on...and it will be tough.


(1) Note that I said "most people" and not "most politicians"...
(2) By "non-violent" I mean not consisting of open hostilities... there has been sparse clashes, and many human rights abuses
(3) We definitely need a Malagasy version of the X-Presidents
(4) As you might expect, there are dozens (hundreds?) of parties and no one really knows what their platforms are, aside from "reconciliation" and "supporting the homeland"

Friday, August 19, 2011

A Drink and a Video for the Weekend

Ready to ring in the weekend with a refreshing beverage? Take a look at this photo essay by my fellow RPCV detailing Madagascar's favorite village drink.

As for our Friday Music Video, we are going away from the "popular Malagasy videos of the last 2 years" to dig a bit deeper, going back a few years. This video may be my all-time favorite, as it features Jesus dance-fighting the devil! (The refrain is: Jesus, yes? Yea Yea! the Devil, yes? NO NO!). Here is Tsiliva's "Oui Oui"

Friday, August 12, 2011

Friday Music Video - Lola

I'm in the middle of a move and have not been posting much, but I wanted to make sure to get a happy Malagasy jam up for the weekend. Here is Lola's "Milalalala" (Lola always has great dancers, so enjoy!)

Friday, August 5, 2011

Tourism Stats and Friday Music Video

Before we start the weekend with a jam by Malagasy artist Y-zit, I wanted to briefly touch upon a link regarding tourism (if you would like to see a much longer take on my own recent tourism in Ethiopia, check out the previous post). The link in question is the Economist's brief note on tourism revenues (h/t A View from the Cave). This article notes that Madagascar earns a very high revenue per tourist. This is encouraging news for the tourism sector in Madgascar. The Economist explains this high receipts per tourist like this:
When calculated as the total of tourist receipts divided by the total number of arrivals, several geographically isolated countries fare well. This may be because holidaymakers will stay longer and fork out more on a long-distance trip.
So when tourists go to a distant and isolated place like Madagascar, they will spend a lot of money to make the most out of their trip. But tourism proponents should not get too excited by this study, as it merely points out the high rate of return per tourist. If you click through to the paper (pdf) that the Economist bases this table on, you will see that Madagascar's overall tourism numbers are still pathetically small. In 2010, there were 196,000 tourists to Madagascar (up from the first year of the crisis, 2009, but still no where near the pre-crisis 2008 number of 375,000). Madagascar is the fourth largest island nation in the world, and boasts unique rainforests, beautiful beaches, amazing Tsingy formations, and a vibrant culture. Yet its tourism numbers are dwarfed by the much smaller neighboring islands of Mauritius (935,000 in 2010) and Reunion (421,000 in 2010). Ouch...

Ok one more Madagascar link... It looks like one of the Bush boys has been visiting Madagascar, looking for investment opportunities. While some see his meeting with President Rajoelina as a sign of recognition for the regime, I think it is just an example of a businessman looking to invest in Madagascar's rich resources. Madagascar certainly could use more international investment, even if it means dealing with a corrupt regime. And as others are calling for an end to sanctions based on humanitarian reasons (which would legitimize this government), why not allow a businessman to explore possibilities for investment in Madagascar? Of course, the terms "Bush," "oil," and "Rajoelina" elicit strong reactions in many observers. I do enjoy the photo in the Africa Review's article, where it looks like Neil Bush was preparing to shake Andry's hand until an aid yelled at him: "Stop!"

Now to continue the tradition of featuring some of Madagascar's most popular songs from the past two years (and start the weekend on a relaxing note), here is "Fo Mijaly" (A Suffering Heart) by Y-zit

Thursday, August 4, 2011

Traveling in Northern Ethiopia

I should start by warning that this is a long post (but it is full of pictures!) - About two months ago, while returning from Madagascar to the United States, I took a week-long detour to visit a friend serving in the Peace Corps in Ethiopia (yes, I am just getting around to writing about it now). This Peace Corps Volunteer (PCV), Chase, and I flew from Addis Ababa to the northern part of the country, where we toured some of the ancient historic sites. Ethiopians are proud of their rich culture and history, and I understood why: it is a remarkable country. Here are some of the thoughts and observations I took away from the visit...

Ethiopia
The birthplace of coffee. The home of the Queen of Sheba. The location of important anthropological discoveries. The final resting place of the Ark of the Covenant. One of the first countries to adopt Christianity.

These are just a few of Ethiopia's claims to fame. The Ethiopian people are proud of these historical and legndary claims. Some other sources of pride include their complex languages, their diverse population (over 80 ethnic groups), the Rift Valley environment, their culinary history, and their position of leadership in Africa (home to the African Union and powerful leaders past and present). But the greatest source of pride for Ethiopians is the fact that, with the exception of a brief Italian occupation (1936-41), Ethiopia has never been colonized. In this sense, it is unique amongst African nations.

Physically, the country is as diverse as its people. The north is mountainous, dry, and dusty. The south-east is also semi-desert and dry (and affected by the current famine in the region). In between these areas runs the Great Rift Valley, from south-west to north-east, and this area has lush vegetation and diverse wildlife. The entire country is landlocked, and it is surrounded by some dangerous regimes (here's a list of its neighbors: Somalia, Sudan, South Sudan, Eritrea, Djibouti, Kenya). Along with the lack of a coastline (most exports are sent through Djibouti) and questionable relationships with its neighbors, Ethiopia also started an international row by beginning the construction of a major hydroelectric dam on the Nile River. While the source of the Blue Nile lies in Ethiopia (at Lake Tana), because the river is the life-source for other countries in the region, any action taken by Ethiopia that affects the river is seen as a threat to these countries (notably Egypt).

Ethiopia has an interesting cultural and religious legacy. Until the 1980's, it was home to a large Jewish population. During this decade, due to war and famine, many made their way to Israel (via Israeli transport in airlifts like Operation Moses) and few Jews remain in Ethiopia. Currently, most of the population are practicing Christians, with about 15% practicing Islam. Another religious legacy of Ethiopia involves Rastafarianism. Rastafaris believe that Emperor Haile Selassie, the self-proclaimed "Lion of Judah," is Jesus incarnate as prophesied in Revelations. This belief is due to the teachings of Marcus Garvey, as his followers saw Selassie's crowning (he ruled from 1930-1974) as proof of Garvey's predictions of a black king in Africa.

Perhaps the first thing that comes to mind when people think of Ethiopia (well, after coffee) is food. Both for the variety of delicious cuisine and for the much-publicized famines that have affected the region (Ethiopian famine was the inspiration for this). But let's focus on the food: if you've been to an Ethiopian restaurant, you know the food is tasty and unique. The meals center around injera, a spongy flatbread that you eat with your hands and use to scoop up various types of wats (sauces or stews). The wats range from bland to spicy, and can include all sorts of tasty meats. I actually prefer the injera firfir, which is a breakfast meal consisting of injera used to eat... leftover refried injera! Here is a video clip of Bizarre Foods' Andrew Zimmern tasting some injera and wat:



Addis Ababa
Addis, the capital of Ethiopia, is a pretty special city. The first word I can think of to describe it is: HUGE. The city is sprawling and full of large buildings and wide boulevards. It just seemed so spacious to me. I probably had this impression because I was comparing it to Madagascar's capital, Antananarivo. Antananarivo was basically a village that became a city in 1625. It grew upon its original structure, meaning buildings were crammed wherever they would fit, and roads snaked up and down the hillsides. The town became a capital, and for hundreds of years saw new structures built on top of old ones, with little space to expand the infrastructure to meet the needs of a modern society (creating awful traffic). This contrasts with  Addis, which was a planned capital built in the late nineteenth century. The city was founded in 1886 by Menelik II. It is the home to the African Union and numerous other international missions.

Mekele and Hawzien
Chase and I flew from Addis to Mekele to begin our northern adventure. Mekele is the capital of the Tigray region, and a good launching-point for tours of the areas historical sites. From Mekele we made our way to Hawzien, where our friend Corey is working with the Millenium Villages Project. From Hawzien, we went to some of the incredible rock-hewn churches in the countryside.
Exterior of a rock church, carved out of the surrounding mountainside, dating back to the early years of Christianity in Ethiopia.
Some artwork in the interior of the church.
Some of the churches were built on cliff-sides to protect the priests and monks from persecution. Some such churches are only accessible by scaling a cliff-side by rope! (We did not do this, but we did hike up to one remote church as seen below)
Atop the mountain to find a hidden church

A long way down...

There is the entrance to the church

Literally built into the mountain!

Here is the cool eco-lodge we stayed at in Hawzien, Gheralta Lodge:


It was an excellent hotel, with delicious prepared dinners, it's own organic garden, great mountainous views, comfortable bungalows, and an all-around cool vibe. Their website puts it best:
Enrica and Silvio Rizzotti aim to offer a family style resort– but with impeccable standards of finishing, maintenance and cleanliness – and good, simple cooking prepared with local products.
Axum
From Hawzien, Chase and I hopped a bus and then a truck to get to Axum. We rode through mountainous ridges with beautiful views, passing by roads that led to Eritrea to the north (and were probably heavily guarded along the border - lingering hard feelings from the Ethiopian-Eritrean War). We ended up in Axum, the centerpiece of the ancient Axumite kingdom and the main city in Ethiopia's Christian history. Besides its religious history, the area is home to many impressive archaeological sites. There are so many sites that many have yet to be discovered; for example, a farmer came up to me and Chase with a 4th century Christian coin he found in his garden, and an Archaeologist recently discovered this major palace more or less by accident:
Palaital Remains
Also in Axum there are a series of large stone towers, known as stelae. They date from Pre-Christian times and signify burial sites of major rulers.
The remains of a stelae structure next to some of the still-standing stelae.
This distant view puts the size of the stelae in perspective.





When Emperor Haile Selassie's wife visited Axum, she wanted to pray at the ancient Church of St. Mary of Zion. But the holy site did not allow women to worship there, so the Emperor commissioned a larger church to accommodate the faithful of both genders.
The old St. Mary's of Zion church (this one dates from the 17th century, although it is built on the ruins of the original church built in the 300s AD)

Some of the interior artwork at the old church
More artwork (note the Trinity depiction at the top)
The large domed structure to the left is the massive new Church of St. Mary of Zion
Interior of the new St. Mary's of Zion Church
This bible dates from around 400AD, and they still use it in special masses at the new church.
For a long time, I thought I knew where the Ark of the Covenant was located. Turns out I was wrong. According to legend, the son of King Solomon and the Queen of Sheba, Menelik, went to Jerusalem to visit his father, and left with the Ark (Ethiopians are quick to point out that this was a gift and not stolen property). The Ark has resided for years in Axum, in the lower level of a monastery, with no one allowed admittance except a single caretaker priest (who cannot leave until he dies and is replaced by a new priest). I imagine his death is quickened if he decides to sneak a peak inside the Ark...
According to legend, this is the location of the Ark of the Covenant
After Axum, we flew back to Addis, and then I headed back to the USofA. The trip was a whirlwind, but definitely worth it.

Lessons
So, what did I learn from these travels?
1) Whenever possible, try to visit and travel with a PCV (or similarly-embedded friend) when visiting a developing country. Their knowledge of the local language and culture offers you a completely different experience than traveling alone or only with foreign companions. Plus most PCVs love the chance to travel within the country they are working, since they often take their vacation trips to other countries due to cheap travel (at least those serving in mainland Africa do; Madagascar PCVs are more isolated and usually just vacation at the nearest beach).
2) The pride that the Ethiopian people have for their country is impressive. In Mekele, for example, I saw two working-class Ethiopians who had saved up money just to travel to the north from Addis and see the remains of palaces and bask in their inherited history. I rarely saw such pride in Madagascar. Obviously Madagascar is a "newer" country, with less ancient historical sites, but the sites it does have (like the Queen's palace in Antananarivo or Jean Laborde's facilities in Mantasoa) are in poor condition. And we will not even get into the country's amazing natural heritage...
2a) To continue upon this difference in outlooks - Malagasy often look for foreign ways to do things and latch on to foreign culture. For instance, when promoting SRI (an improved rice-farming method) to Malagasy, I would emphasize that it originated in Madagascar. I was told by Malagasy extension workers to stop saying this, because most Malagasy believed that ideas from Madagascar were flawed and foreign ideas were inherently better. If they thought SRI came from Madagascar, they would be less likely to try the method!
3) For all of its impressive history and heritage, Ethiopia is one of the poorest nations in the world. This dichotomy really hit home for me when I saw this written in the guestbook at an Axum museum, from a Kenyan tourist:
Wow, what an amazing culture and history you have. You were so far ahead... what happened?



NB: Because languages in Ethiopia have their own characters and written form, all place names and words are transliterated into English as best as possible. Sometimes words are spelled differently in different places. A few examples in case you are searching for any of the places in this article: Axum/Aksum, Addis Ababa/Addis Abeba, Mekele/Makale, and Hawzien/Hawzen.